|
The Bottles of R. F. Johnson/Henry Pfaff/Southwestern Liquor Co.
|
| R. F. Johnson & Co. and El Paso Bottling Company |
| R. F. Johnson Brand
Johnson advertised several products including Sarsaparilla, Vichy, Seltzer, Manitou Table Water, and Ginger Champagne, although he probably bottled other popular flavors of the day. Although he called his plant the El Paso Bottling Company, he also used his own name on some of his bottles. Johnson went into business prior to the successful explosion of crown closures. His bottles, manufactured with two-piece molds and plate molds, had finishes for the Hutchinson- style stoppers that preceded crowns. |
| P 01
Method of Manufacture: Two-Piece Mold Color: Common Green Size (in cm.): 16.2-16.7 (h); 6.3 (d) [15.7 (h); 6.3 (d)] Primary Labeling Style: Embossed (plate) Finish: Hutchinson Capacity: ca. 9 oz. [ca. 8.5 oz.] Overall Bottle Design: Cylindrical with steep shoulder and short neck Front Description Body: Rectangular plate mold with a rounded top (tombstone shaped), embossed with R. F. JOHNSON (downward arch)/CO./EL PASO,/TEX. (all horizontal) [circular plate mold - R. F. Johnson (downward arch)/& CO/EL PASO/TEX (all horizontal)] Back Description Body: Bare Base: Bare Manufacturer: Unknown Dating: [1892-1897] These bottles can likely be dated from the first advertisement for soda water in 1892 until Henry Pfaff's first crown-capped bottle ca. 1897. Collection(s): Becky Garrett Collection, El Paso Museum of History; David Cole collection, Bangs, Texas; author's collection.
|
| After Johnson moved to California, Henry Pfaff switched to a new, crown-capped bottle. |
| P 02
Method of Manufacture: Two-Piece Mold Color: Colorless Size (in cm.): 21.1 (h); 6.2 (d) Primary Labeling Style: Embossed Finish: Crown Capacity: 8.5 oz. Overall Bottle Design: Cylindrical Front Description Body: Embossed - R. F. JOHNSON & CO. (downward arch)/HP (script in center)/EL PASO, TEX. (upward arch) Back Description Body: Bare Base: Embossed - 0 Manufacturer: Unknown - if the 0 is a manufacturer's mark, it is unlisted in Toulouse or other available sources; the mark is likely a zero. Dating: [1897?-1898] Bottles of this type were used at some point after Johnson's relocation to California in 1895 but were probably no longer in use after Pfaff's take-over of the business in late 1898. Because these are very scarce, they were probably in use toward the end of R. F. Johnson & Co. Collection(s): David Cole collection, Bangs, Texas.
|
| El Paso Bottling Co.
Only two styles of El Paso Bottling Company containers have been discovered in El Paso. Although these containers used a Hutchinson finish, Johnson used at least one other finish style--one of the lightning-style closures. The lightning closures used a wire arrangement to seal a bottle with a cork or ceramic stopper that could be opened or closed by manipulating the wires. Such closures were unusual in El Paso, but white ceramic stoppers exist with EL PASO BOTTLING CO printed in an outlined circle around TEX. The bottles they sealed were apparently unembossed and may have contained paper labels.
|
| P 03
Method of Manufacture: Two-Piece Mold Color: Common Green Size (in cm.): 17.5 (h); 6.5 (d) [17.8 (h); 6.4 (d)] [16.9 (h); 6.4 (d)] Primary Labeling Style: Embossed Finish: Hutchinson Capacity: ca. 9 oz.; ca. 9 oz. Overall Bottle Design: Cylindrical Front Description Body: Embossed - (tombstone shaped plate mold) EL PASO (downward arch)/BOTTLING (more gentle arch)/COMPANY (horizontal) Note that the letters in COMPANY grow progressively smaller until the letter P then expand again. [(circular plate mold) EL PASO (downward arch)/BOTTLING (horizontal)/COMPANY. (upward arch)] Back Description Body: Bare Base: Bare [Embossed - EP] Manufacturer: Unknown Dating: [1892-1895 or later] The bottles can be dated from 1892 to at least 1895 when Johnson stopped advertising El Paso Bottling Company but may have continued until Pfaff's take over in late 1898. Collection(s): Robert Sproull collection; Rick Chavez collection; author's collection.
|
| Henry Pfaff
Although Pfaff only advertised soda and mineral waters prior to 1906, he undoubtedly distributed water from Manitou Mineral Water Co., a product carried by his predecessor, R. F. Johnson. He may only have added Buffalo Lithia Water in 1906, although it may have been carried earlier. Both waters were likely continued until Pfaff sold out to Southwestern Liquor in 1907. |
| Henry Pfaff Brand
Unlike Johnson, Pfaff used only one container style manufactured in two-piece molds, topped with the earliest datable crown caps in El Paso (1898). |
| P 04
Method of Manufacture: Two-Piece Mold Color: Colorless; Light Blue; Solarized Amethyst Size (in cm.): 20.5-21.3 (h); 6.3 (d) Primary Labeling Style: Embossed Finish: Crown Capacity: ca. 9 oz. Overall Bottle Design: Cylindrical [two variations differ slightly in the curvature of neck and shoulder but are otherwise alike] Front Description Body: Embossed - HENRY PFAFF (downward arch)/EL PASO,/TEXAS. (horizontal) Back Description Body: Bare Base: Bare Manufacturer: Unknown Dating: [1898-1907] Bottles of this type were probably used during the full tenure of Henry Pfaff from late 1898 to 1907. Collection(s): Becky Garrett collection, El Paso Museum of History; John Gross Collection; Mike Morrison collection; Rick Chavez collection; Betty Wood collection; author's collection.
|
| Buffalo Lithia Water
Buffalo Springs (also known as Buffalo Lithia Springs and Buffalo Mineral Springs) are located in Mecklenurg, Virginia. The Springs were known to Europeans as early as 1728 and operated as a commercial enterprise from about 1811 to the early 1940s. The Springs featured a hotel and health resort and opened a bottling plant around the turn of the century that sold water from Spring No. 2. Bottled water was sold after 1876 but was bottled by hand and transported by wagon to the nearest railway prior to the opening of the bottling plant. By the 1880s, Buffalo Lithia Springs shipped bottled water in twelve-bottle cases of half-gallon containers priced at five dollars per case. By the 1930s, water was also available in five-gallon demi-johns. At its peak, Buffalo Springs water was sold in an estimated 20,000 drug stores throughout Europe, Canada, and the United States. Although the hotel closed in the early 1940s, the owners of the property continued to sell bottled water until 1949 (Abbott et al 1997:19-58). The earliest known containers used for Buffalo Lithia Water were half-gallon, common green bottles with cork stoppers. The embossed picture of a woman with a pitcher (see below) was part of the registered trademark. During the late 1920s or early 1930s (before the change to paper labels) the company made a slight alteration in the name to Buffalo Mineral Water. By the 1930s, black and white paper labels were affixed to otherwise undecorated bottles, along with a change to continuous thread (screw top) caps. By this time most of the bottles were colorless, although some of the common green containers persisted (Abbott et al 1997:52). Buffalo Mineral Springs Water bottles were identical except for the name and size. Because of hand completion of the finish in the two-piece mold process, bottle heights varied (cf. Blumenstein 1973:52-53; Colcleaser 1966:43; Klamkin 1971:144). Bottles used in El Paso were cork-stoppered with the name, Buffalo Lithia Water. Carlo & Dorothy Sellari added an interesting note about Lithia Waters: Following the Civil War, at a time when sales of mineral water began to drop, excessive boasts began to appear that lithium, an alkali metal supposedly with healing properties, was in the water. An investigation after the passage of the Pure Food and Drug Act in 1907 found only infinitesimal traces of lithium in bottled water. "Lithia Water" abruptly disappeared from bottle labels (Sellari & Sellari 1989:84). The Sellaris (1989:28), however, noted that Spring No. 2 "was the only spring at Buffalo that contained significant amounts of lithia, considered a rare and valuable ingredient in mineral springs." According to the Ferraros, the same report claimed that "in order to receive an effective therapeutic dosage of lithium in BUFFALO LITHIA SPRINGS WATER the patient would have to drink 200,000 gallons of the water!" (Ferraro & Ferraro 1966:51). |
| P 05
Method of Manufacture: Two-Piece Mold Color: Common Green Size (in cm.): 25.1-25.4 (h); 11.4-11.7 (d) Primary Labeling Style: Embossed Finish: Single-Collar (for corks) Capacity: Half Quart Overall Bottle Design: Cylindrical with rounded shoulder and short neck Front Description Body: Embossed - BUFFALO/LITHIA WATER above a picture of a well-dressed, seated woman pouring something from a pitcher with NATURES/MATERIA/MEDICA to the left of and slightly below the pitcher and TRADE MARK below the woman (variations in the picture range from crude to precise and include pleats or plain skirts on the woman) Heel: Bare Back Description Body: Bare Heel: Embossed - O B CO Base: Embossed - 845/5 Manufacturer: Ohio Bottle Co. (1904-1905) Although Toulouse (1971:399-400) only lists a mark of O B C (no CO) and claims the firm was created to use an Owens machine, no other known glass house had a name that would even remotely fit the initials O B CO. Ohio Bottling Co. was born of a merger of three existing firms, all of which had previously manufactured blown- in-mold or two-piece mold bottles. Dating: [1906 or earlier-1909] Although Henry Pfaff only advertised Buffalo Lithia Water beginning in 1906, he may have sold it earlier when his ads were less specific. When Pfaff sold out to Southwestern Liquor Company in 1907, they continued to advertise the water until 1909. Collection(s): Author's collection.
|
| Malt-Nutrine
On April 24, 1903, Pfaff first advertised Anheuser-Busch's Malt-Nutrine, "the perfect malt tonic. A food in liquid form. It quickly builds flesh and tissue. . . . All druggists sell it. . . .Orders promptly filled by HY. PFAFF, Wholesale Dealer, El Paso" (EPH 4/24/1903 5:6). The illustration in the ad depicted a squat beer-style bottle with a paper label and foil-wrapped beer- style finish (for a cork stopper). The label declared ANHEUSER-BUSCH'S/Malt Nutrine (script)/A NON INTOXICANT/SPARKLING/A. . . CONCENTRATED LIQUID EXTRACT/OF MALT HOPS. The Anheuser Busch emblem occupied the bottom center of the label with [illegible]/Anheuser Busch/ST. LOUIS to the left and [illegible]Brewing Co.[?]/MO. to the right. By 1906, Pfaff's name no longer accompanied the ad. Malt extracts were apparently popular during the early part of the twentieth century. Other brewers produced Malt Marrow (McAvoy Brewing), Malt Sinew (Conrad Seipp Brewing), Malta (Jacob Schmidt Brewing), Digesto (Theodore Hamm), and Cream of Malt Tonic (Kiewel Brewing Co.). These various malt products were marketed with the usual unbelievably long list of curative or health-producing qualities that were common at the time (Ketchum 1999:6-7). Non-intoxicating malt beverages were produced to take advantage of the food value in beer. Higher in solid content than alcoholic beers, they were usually called tonics or malt extracts and were generally sold in drug stores. Like the Malt-Nutrine sold by Pfaff, most of these were packaged in long-necked, squat bottles (Kay 2001:12).
|
| Southwestern Liquor Company
Southwestern advertised Manitou Mineral Water Company from 1908 until 1916. Buffalo Lithia Water only appeared in the ads in 1908 and 1909. In 1910, the firm began advertising Clysmic "King of Table Waters," and continued the ads until 1915 (EPCD 1908-1916). Thus far, I have been unable to locate any identifiable soda or mineral water bottles or stoppers from Southwestern Liquor Company. |
| Clysmic "King of Table Waters"
Clysmic was bottled in Waukesha, Wisconsin, from 1878 to 1907. Clysmic "King of Table Waters" appeared in 1907 and continued to be bottled until 1919. The lady and the elk label (see below) was also used during this time period (personal communication, John Schoenknecht). Like the waters described above, I have been unable to find local examples of Clysmic "King of Table Waters." Kendrick (1963:78), however, depicts the base and partial body of a Clysmic bottle in her demonstration of the distinctive Owns Ring. The bottle contains the word, CLYSMIC, embossed on the base, but the portion shown has no marking on the body itself. It seems clear that the product was solely marked with a paper label, leaving only the base as an identifyer in most archaeological contexts. Two "bowling pin" style bottles have been offered on eBay. Both are made from different shdes of green glass and are topped by a crown finish. Each has a slightly different style of embossing on the base. At least two Clysmic trays also have
been offered on eBay. One is labeled clockwise around the inside
Clysmic (logo) King of Table Waters, Cheinco Housewares (logo), Clysmic
(logo), King of Table Waters. Both trays show a scantily-clad lady posed
next to a stag. The lady holds a gigantic bottle of Clysmic.
|
| Manitou Ginger Champagne
Although Southwestern did not specifically advertise ginger champagne, it was a product of Manitou Mineral Water Company and had been previously offered by R. F. Johnson and probably Henry Pfaff. The first non-Native American to see the waters that would become Manitou Springs was Lieutenant George Fredercik Ruxton in 1847. Both Indians and Whites visited the springs until "Uncle Dick" Wooten built a cabin near Soda Spring in 1859. The town of La Font was laid out in 1871, but the name was changed to Manitou a year later. The springs were very popular, and, by the 1880s, Manitou was known as the "Saratoga of the West" (Daniels & McConnell [1964] 1973:7-15, 22). The Manitou Mineral Water Co. built a bottling plant at Navajo Spring in 1872 and became noted for its Manitou Ginger Champagne. Between July and December of 1886, the plant sold 70,000 bottles of water. Business was so good that a glass factory was built in Colorado City to supply the bottling plant (Daniels & McConnell [1964] 1973:32-34). The Colorado City Glass Co. was incorporated in 1889 and employed 26 men. Glass laborers worked in two shifts to produce about 14,000 daily. A disastrous fire struck the plant in September 1892, but J. B. Wheeler, the principal stockholder of the company, had a new plant rebuilt and in operation by May 1893, but the operation failed later that year due to the great 1893 depression (Clint 1976:41). A new plant was built in 1889 with a 20,000 quart per day output capacity. Manitou Mineral Water Co. was sold about 1913, but the new owner was unpopular with the only man who knew the process used for making Manitou Ginger Champagne. As a result, the product was removed from the market, although the effervescent water, bottled only with natural gas from the springs, continued to be sold (Daniels & McConnell [1964] 1973:32-34). It is unknown when bottling operations ceased. Along with the embossed bottles described below,
Manitou sold Ginger Champagne in bottles with paper labels on both body
and neck/shoulder. The body labels bore a drawing of an Indian above
ORIGINAL/MANITOU/GINGER CHAMPAGNE/PALE DRY (Prebble 1987:46). When the
company switched from embossed to paper labels is unknown. Some of
the cork-stoppered bottles were topped a porcelain caps that identified
the product inside.
Manitou Springs is still in operation today, mostly as a tourist Mecca with gift and craft shops, natural sites (e.g. Seven Falls), and a set of Anasazi Cliff Dwellings that were removed from their prehistoric setting and relocated near the town. Although bottling has long ceased, the five original springs and five additional drilled springs are still available to tourists and local citizens who fill plastic jugs at the various locations throughout the town. Each spring has a slightly (and sometimes distinctly) different taste. |
| P 06
Method of Manufacture: Machine Color: Colorless Size (in cm.): 24.8 (h); 7.0 (d) Primary Labeling Style: Embossed Finish: Crown Capacity: ca. 17 oz. Overall Bottle Design: Cylindrical Front Description Body: Embossed - ORIGINAL/Manitou (script)/GINGER CHAMPAGNE/TRADE MARK REGESTERED/MANITOU COLORADO Back Description Body: Bare Heel: Embossed - 14 1 (to right side) Base: Owens Ring Manufacturer: Unknown Dating: [1892-1913] Bottles of Ginger Champagne were sold at least as early as 1889 (Preble 1987:46), although crown finish bottles could not have been used prior to 1892. All bottles used by R. F. Johnson (beginning in 1892), Henry Pfaff, and Southwestern Liquor Co. may have used crown finishes. Ginger Champagne was probably sold by Southwestern until the cessation of its production at Manitou about 1913. Collection(s): Author's collection.
|
| Some of the early Manitou waters had knurled porcelain caps glued to the cork stoppers. These added to expense but gave a touch of elegance to table waters as well as being easier to grasp and remove (Jones 1962). |
| Ute Chief Mineral Water
Ute Chief is one of the many springs found in Manitou, and the Ute Chief brand was also bottled in that town. The company was in business as the Ute Chief Mineral Water Co. from 1900 to 1944 (Preble 1987:46) . There is no direct evidence or advertising that Ute Chief was sold in El Paso, although the timeline is reasonable for its inclusion. |
| P 07
Method of Manufacture: Two-Piece Mold Color: Solarized Amethyst Size (in cm.): 21.5 (h); 6.4 (d) Primary Labeling Style: Embossed Finish: Crown Capacity: ca. 10 oz. Overall Bottle Design: Cylindrical Front Description Body: Embossed - UTE CHIEF (downward arch)/MINERAL/WATER CO./MANITOU,/COLO. (all horizontal) Heel: Bare Back Description Body: Bare Heel: Bare Base: Embossed - U. C. Manufacturer: Unknown Dating: [1900-ca. 1920] Ute Chief Mineral Water Co. did not operate under that name until 1900. Both the use of manganese as a decolorant (creating the amethyst color) and the use of the two-piece mold technique had mostly faded from the soda bottle producers by 1920. Collection(s): Author’s collection.
|
| The Manitou
A final bottle style was manufactured using the two-piece mold method, also had a crown finish, and a plate mold. The mold was embossed THE MANITOU (downward arch)/NET CONTENTS/9 FL. OZ. (both horizontal)/RDO. MIN. SPGS. CO. (upward arch). The heel was embossed THIS BOTTLE NOT TO BE SOLD (Clint 1976:173). |
| Table
of Contents
Chapter 7a - Sweeney and Woodlawn |